Figures (2)  Tables (1)
    • Figure 1. 

      Comparison of flowering phenology between annual and perennial woody plants. The life cycle of flowering plants can be considered as a succession of distinct growth phases: vegetative growth, followed by a reproductive phase and eventually seed set and senescence. Annuals are fast cyclers and only need several months from the stage of vegetative development to flowering, and complete their life cycle within one growing season (a). While perennial woody plants experience a prolonged vegetative phase with many years until the first onset of flowering. Following first-time flowering, trees undergo seasonal flowering throughout their lifespan (b). Tree’s seasonal flowering can mainly be divided into 'direct' and 'indirect' flowering types, based on whether the development from initiation to emergence is interrupted or includes a period of rest. The 'indirect' flowering is common among temperate/boreal trees. It displays extended periods between flower initiation and flower blooming, in which flowers initiate in the summer are dormant through the winter, and the trees do not blossom until the following spring. In comparison, 'direct' flowering is common among subtropical or tropical evergreen species. They finish their complete reproductive cycles during a single growing season without dormancy or a rest period. VPC, vegetative phase change; RPC, reproductive phase change.

    • Figure 2. 

      Molecular pathways of flowering phenology, and their shared mechanisms in seasonal vegetative growth regulation in Populus, the model tree for perennial plant phenology study. Flowering is split into two dimensions: one is the first onset of flowering after many years of juvenile and adult vegetative growth; another is seasonal flowering after reproductive maturity. Conserved to herbaceous plants, the juvenile to adult vegetative phase change is mainly regulated by two microRNAs, miR156 and miR172. The first onset of flowering is controlled by FT/TFL1 family genes and their downstream integrators such as AP1 and LFY. As trees will undergo a long period of adult vegetative stage until floral induction, how miR156/miR172 module regulate age-dependent flowering in trees remains an open question. Unlike in Arabidopsis, GA usually inhibits flowering in diverse woody angiosperms. Whether GA regulates flowering through SOC1-like genes, and do SOC1-like genes control reproductive competence in trees needs further investigation. For seasonal flowering, the expression of flowering integrator genes, such as FT (FT1 and FT2), CENL1, SVL, and LEAFY (LFY), are controlled by seasonal cues like photoperiod and temperature. The specific expression patterns of these genes ensures the tree undergoes floral initiation at a specific time of the year. Meanwhile, these flowering integrator genes also play key roles in the seasonal activity-dormancy vegetative growth, including photoperiod-induced growth cessation of shoot apex at the end of summer, dormancy induction in autumn, cold-induced release of dormancy in winter, and warm temperature-induced bud burst in spring. Thus, trees have evolved an ability to incorporate the environmental signal to different developing events. the diagram sketch of seasonal growth from the inside out represent seasons, the expression pattens of flowering integrator genes, the seasonal flowering events, the seasonal vegetative growth events and environment signals such as photoperiod (LD and SD, long day and short day) and temperature (high and low) respectively.

    • SpeciesGeneConstructionFloweringOther effectsReferences
      Apple
      (Malus pumila Mill.)
      MdFT1OverexpressionA,NInduction[43]
      MdTFL1, MdTFL1.1
      MdCENa, MdCENb
      CRISPR/RNAiA,T,NRepression[45,159161]
      AFL1, AFL2OverexpressionA,NInduction[162,163]
      MdDAMa, MdDAMb, MdDAMc
      MdSVPa, MdSVPb
      RNAiNInductionRegulates bud dormancy[135]
      MdFLC1
      MdFLC3
      OverexpressionARepressionJuvenility regulation[164]
      Avocado
      (Persea americana)
      PaFTOverexpressionAInduction[165]
      Blueberry
      (Vaccinium corymbosum L.)
      VcFTOverexpressionT,NInduction[166]
      Birch (Betula)BpAP1OverexpressionNInduction[68]
      Citrus (Citrus sinensis)CsTFLOverexpressionARepression[167]
      Citrus
      (Citrus clementina)
      CsAP1Stress-inducible promoterNInduction[168]
      CsLFYStress-inducible promoterNInduction[168]
      CsSL1, CsSL2OverexpressionAInduction[52]
      Dogwood (Cornus L.)CorcanTFL1, CorfloTFL1OverexpressionARepression[169]
      Eucalyptus
      (Eucalyptus spp.)
      AtFTOverexpressionNInduction[152]
      PtFT1OverexpressionNInduction
      ELFYCRISPRAffects floral development[170]
      EgSVPOverexpressionARepressionAffects floral development[171]
      Fig (Ficus carica)FcFT1OverexpressionTInduction[172]
      MagnoliaceaeMawuAP1OverexpressionAInduction[173]
      Grapevine (Vitis spp.)VvTFL1AOverexpressionARepression[174]
      VvFTOverexpressionAInduction
      Japanese apricot
      (Prunus mume)
      PmFTOverexpressionAInduction[175]
      PmTFL1OverexpressionARepression
      Jatropha
      (Jatropha curcas L.)
      JcFTOverexpression /RNAiA,NInduction[36,176]
      JcLFYOverexpressionA,NInductionAffects floral fruit and seed development[177,178]
      JcAP1OverexpressionAInduction[179]
      JcTFL1a, JcTFL1b, JcTFL1cOverexpressionA,NRepression[180]
      JcTFL1RNAiNInduction
      Kiwifruit
      (Actinidia spp.)
      AcFT1, AcFT2OverexpressionA,NInduction[181,182]
      AcCEN1, AcCEN2,
      AcCEN3, AcCEN4
      Overexpression/CRISPRARepression[47,181,182]
      AcBFT1, AcBFT2, AcBFT3Overexpression/CRISPRARepressionAffects dormancy and bud break[182,183]
      SVP1-4OverexpressionA,T,NNormalAffects dormancy[142,184,185]
      AcSOC1e, AcSOC1f, AcSOC1iOverexpressionAInduction
      NNormal
      Affects dormancy[54]
      AcFLCLOverexpression/CRISPRRegulate bud break[123]
      Litchi
      (Litchi chinensis Sonn.)
      LcFT1, LcFT2OverexpressionA,TInduction[186]
      London plane
      (Platanus acerifolia)
      PaFTOverexpressionAInduction
      TInduction
      [187]
      Longan
      (Dimocarpus longan L.)
      DlFT1OverexpressionAInduction[188]
      DlFT2OverexpressionARepression
      Loquat
      (Eriobotrya japonica)
      EjTFL1-1, EjTFL1-2OverexpressionARepression[189]
      EjSOC1-1, EjSOC1-2OverexpressionAcenter[51]
      EjLFY-1OverexpressionSInduction[190]
      Mango
      (Mangiferaindica L.)
      MiFT1OverexpressionAInduction[191]
      MiFT2; MiTFL1-1, MiTFL1-2,
      MiTFL1-3, MiTFL1-4
      OverexpressionARepression[191,192]
      Norway spruce
      (Picea abies)
      PaFTL1, PaFTL2OverexpressionARepression[193]
      PaFTL2OverexpressionControl growth arrest[119]
      Olive (Olea europaea L.)OeFT1, OeFT2OverexpressionAInduction[194]
      Peach
      (Prunus persica L.)
      PpTFL1OverexpressionARepression[195]
      PpAP1OverexpressionAInduction[196]
      PpFTOverexpressionAInduction[197]
      Pear
      (Pyrus communis L.)
      PcTFL1-1, PcTFL1-2RNAiNInduction[151]
      PcFT2OverexpressionTInduction
      NNormal
      Regulate vegetative growth[198]
      PcTFL1.1CRISPRNInduction[159]
      Pomegranate
      (Punica granatum L.)
      PgTFL1, PgCENaOverexpressionARepression[199]
      Poplar
      (Populus spp.)
      FT1, FT2Overexpression/CRISPRNInductionFT1 regulates bud break; FT2 regulates growth cessation[34,44,
      103,117]
      LAP1Overexpression/RNAiAInductionRegulates growth cessation[200]
      PopCEN1, PopCEN2Overexpression/RNAiNRepressionRegulates bud break[46]
      SVLOverexpression/RNAiNRepressionRegulate growth cessation, dormancy and bud break[139,140,
      143,144]
      Rubber trees
      (Hevea brasiliensis)
      HbMFT1OverexpressionARepression[201]
      Sweet Cherry
      (Prunus avium L.)
      PavFTOverexpressionAInduction[202]
      PavSVPOverexpressionARepression[203]
      PavSOC1OverexpressionAInduction[55]
      PaAP1OverexpressionAInduction[204]
      Tea-oil tree
      (Camellia oleifera Abel.)
      CoFT1OverexpressionAInduction[205]
      Trifoliate orange
      (Poncirus trifoliate)
      CiFTOverexpressionA,NInduction[35,38,206]
      N, A, T and S represent function assessed in native plant, Arabidopsis, tobacco and strawberry respectively.

      Table 1. 

      Functional orthologs of flowering integrator genes identified in perennial trees.