-
Considering the four dimensions noted earlier in this paper, the study has generated aggregated thematic experiences about food security. The aggregated thematic experiences are then further classified into four categories comprising perspectives on food security. The study runs the NVivo software to generate codes from people's statements and afterwards themes are created. Based on these themes, the following sub-themes reflected the three dimensions in terms of content, context, and process of food security (Table 1).
Table 1. Four pillars.
Theme 1 Food availability and people's livelihood 1.1 Daily foods are not continuously physically obtainable
1.2 Lack of domestic food production, the inadequate purchasing capacity of daily essentialsTheme 2 Food accessibility and livelihoods
of rural people2.1 Less accessibility to obtain daily foodstuffs without problems posed by the time taken to get them 2.2 Physical features of senior citizens, women, and children considering their safety and transportation costs etc 2.3 Limited access to raw vegetables, meat, and other perishable foods Theme 3 Utilization of food and livelihood
of household3.1 Less capacity to purchase adequate nutritious and safe foodstuffs 3.2 Limited household income to purchase daily necessary foods 3.3 Food quality and health outcomes Theme 4 Food stability, and people's livelihoods 4.1 Less ability to buy sufficient food on a periodic basis 4.2 Food security is temporal, seasonal, or chronically short 4.3 Instability of food production, volatile price, employment instability, import flow instability, and political unrest situation Source: Field work, 2022 Food availability and people's livelihoods
-
Food availability refers to the extent to which food is always physically and culturally obtainable in a desired amount, structured by food production, distribution, and pattern exchange patterns[12].
Foods are not consistently physically obtainable
-
The study found that healthy foods are less available or sold at a higher price. People can purchase better food in expected quantities if only markets/grocery stores sell fresh foods and vegetables which are available among the residents. The study revealed that the informants do not get the necessary daily foods as they are not easily obtained from the market or grocery shops. People living in rural areas are struggling to cope with the recent food prices and thus maintain a decent livelihood. It is found that with the prices of daily essentials reaching new heights, living one's life in a village is very difficult. One informant commented that, 'earning TK 12k a month and being an unemployed newlywed only adds to the list of struggles that every new couple faces'.
It is found that people go to the Union Parishad Center (UPC) area to purchase daily essentials from the open market sales shop (OMS: an open place where rice, flour, edible oil, and lentils are sold at a price of half rates), hearing the information that the daily foodstuffs are sold here at affordable prices. One informant remarked, 'After reaching here, I noticed that nobody knows whether any food vehicle will come today or not. I came here to leave my other tasks at home. Let's see how I can manage the foodstuff'. The study argued that hundreds of low-income people scramble for the essentials of daily foodstuff from the OMS as the prices continue to soar. It is also found that many returned home without any food as the shops run out of food fast, 'I had to return home empty-handed yesterday. I cannot afford to miss it again today as the prices of rice and flour are too high in the grocery shops or market', stated one informant. The conditions for other people are not different. One informant added, 'I managed one of my friends to be seated here and collect the food. Still, now I could not manage essential foods'. It is found that one housewife with a baby girl came to the place to get some food relief. She shared that, 'It would be better if I could have some food, it would be great for my newborn child to feed some nutritious food'. People could not get rice and flour as the truck did not stop at the place where they went. Therefore, they had to leave the place without receiving any food assistance.
Lack of domestic food production, inadequate purchase capacity of daily foodstuffs
-
The study found that with the prices of fuel and essentials skyrocketing, people struggled to purchase daily foodstuff and only one person had a fixed monthly income. One informant commented, 'I left the OMS place as I have to go out to earn money, otherwise I could not be able to purchase food for tonight! It would be great if I could get some amount of rice from here'. Likewise, an FGD participant stated, 'Staples such as rice, which used to cost us about TK 60 a kilo, now are being sold for almost TK 100. Being able to get all the items that my wife puts on her grocery list within our budget has been next to impossible for the last three months'. According to one FGD informant, 'as the production cost has raised dramatically, the staple food, such as rice and wheat have been seriously disrupted which led to less availability of food stock in the market'.
The prices of fertilizers, such as potassium and urea have rapidly increased, thus local food production has been seriously affected. With many people having little or no income, one informant said: 'I suppose the recent war between Russia and Ukraine led to the shortages of food production in Bangladesh'. Many informants commented that they did not get the required food in the market, and upon asking the informants, they replied that the production of those particular products, such as edible oil, flour, and sugar has been seriously affected by the recent war between Russia and Ukraine. One informant stated, 'Speaking from experience, life for me was much simpler before the world witnessed the Russia-Ukraine war. I only had to ensure that I had enough to cover my room's rent of around TK 5000, fuel for my bike, and food, which cost me another five grand'. Likewise one informant noted that, 'in the last one-year, food and non-food expenditure of fixed-income group has increased a lot. But their income did not'. In this situation, many have to cut costs on entertainment, education, and medical treatment. By doing so, their standard of living is threatened. This has resulted in serious intergenerational impacts.
Food accessibility and rural livelihoods
-
Individual's position in a family or society and poverty has vital roles in determining whether they could gain access to food. In this framework, accessibility focuses on both availability and affordability, shaping a bridge between these two aspects.
The capacity to collect food free from any obstacles posed by transportation time
-
Physical distance is an important factor to have access to food as some people live further from food sources, suffering from more food insecurity. The study found that while increasing food supply through ramped-up production and import is a priority, it is equally important to bring food prices within reach through greater market interventions. One FGD informant stated that, 'the grocery store probably is 40 minutes away. Not necessary to say that I want to walk 5 or 6 miles or have to go on highway road. I feel scared for my little kids. Hence, I have to walk about 6 to 7 miles to purchase foodstuff, you know'. It is found that physical distance to obtain food from various sources has long been a traditional measure of food accessibility. One informant commented that, 'the government must create a national relief fund, instead of separate food programs and project-based initiatives, to provide long-term food assistance to low-income groups'. Islam et al. found that inadequate transportation has been identified as a prevalent barrier for particular social groups, including people with disabilities, socio-economically poor families, and seniors who might not have their own vehicle[30]. The study found a total of 30 people got together in a place near the Union Parishad. A 75-year old man came here just after the Fazer prayer. He said that 'due to the increase in the daily foodstuff, I came to the place for the first time in my life'. This one scenario reflects the wider situation of the other people who attended.
The physical characteristics of senior citizens, their safety, and transportation costs
-
Apart from the physical distance to a grocery shop, another crucial barrier is the lack of physical characteristics, such as, aged, sick, and so on. The study found that aged people living alone highlight the role that spouses and relatives often play in ensuring access to healthy food for seniors who have functional impairments. It is revealed that aged people in a family or community may have limited or no public transportation options to get access to food. One informant commented, 'I am an aged person and thus haven't the ability to obtain food with cheaper prices from another town'.
The study pointed out that finding no other alternative, senior people left the place without any food relief. It showed how people – women, elderly, youth, and minors – in some areas of the village have to wait for hours on end before they have any chance to purchase food. However, not all areas with high concentrations of poor people are visited by OMS distributors or there is a long wait in line without a guarantee of success, due to often insufficient supplies. 'You have to be lucky to get to the head of the line and to still get it', said one FGD informant. Many turn up before sunrise. Some are sick but say they still have to make the effort because they have no other option. There are also old people and individuals with disabilities. According to the informant, the lines of people have been getting longer in recent months; so many people in need of subsidized food had not been seen before the pandemic, or even after. Although grocery prices fell minimally in recent weeks, the majority of the population is struggling to buy food, as various studies suggest[9,31].
Many aged people contended that they came here without having their morning meal and said that cooking will not be possible if they don't get rice from there. One informant confirmed that she 'came here in the early morning, however, till now no foodstuff has been given to any needy people'.
Access to raw vegetables, meat, and other perishable foods
-
Many have already stopped buying meat and fish due to the current uncontrolled economy, and prices of almost every commodity in the market have gone up by about 20% to 25%[9] One informant asserted, 'I used to buy chicken once a week and beef once a month. But due to the current situation, I buy chicken twice a month. I have stopped buying beef. Also, due to the increase in the price of eggs, many have now reduced egg consumption by 50%'. It can be seen that 95% of daily necessities including the raw market have increased in price by 20 to 30%. It is heard in various professions that most people have reduced their daily necessities to economize as much as they can, and have stopped using some products permanently. Almost every year food prices are increasing in Bangladesh due to the low level of production, improper market management, and fraudulent business syndicates run by some top traders. One informant argued that 'the way prices for each product have increased; it is getting quite difficult to manage food with the salary he earns each month'. Buying foodstuff from the bazaar once a day is the norm as is going to bed without having a meal. The hardship conditions reflect the scarcity of food in other parts of the village. One informant argued that 'due to the hike in prices of commodities I can't make both ends meet with that income. So, I have to use up my savings to meet the additional costs'.
Food utilization and people's livelihoods
-
Food quality refers to the dietary content of a specific food which is a more generally useful measure than considering the consumption of any specific food.
The ability to purchase enough safe and nutritious food
-
The study found that the consumption of nutrient foodstuffs, such as meat, fish, pulses, oils, and eggs has seriously decreased, yet these are the major sources of protein and micro-nutrients. One informant stated, 'Sometimes my children asked for more nutritious food, but food ran out too quickly. Because, we are too many. Thus, we have a shortage of foodstuff '. One household pointed out that, 'the food we are getting is not healthy for us. Foodstuff, like white bread and white rice meets the stomach but they are not good quality food. It's all only calories, no nutrition'. Another FGD participant added that, 'we are compelled to choose less healthy food options while also suffering from health complications in turn with nothing left for medical emergencies'.
One informant said, 'The children are getting tired of nutritious foods. They would like to eat fresh fruit and vegetables'. An FGD participant added, 'I don't like to eat more but it should be nutritious and I feel bad as we can't eat better because we stay out here. I understand that our eating behavior affects our health, but this is us out of control to get sufficient amount of nutritious food '.
The study showed that people have to stop purchasing protein foodstuff for their children. Every household head curtailed their daily budget to purchase food. The study also revealed that when shopping for food in the nearby shops or markets, they are purchasing foods regardless of their quality or freshness. One informant asked how we would pass our lives without having minimum food. The people are not buying eggs which are necessary for their daily lives despite their children eating four eggs every day. They can no longer afford to purchase them due to the rising prices of essentials. One FGD participant commented: 'People are being forced to spend less for food because they can't cut the spending on rent, utilities, and healthcare', he said. He added that people are reducing eating protein from their shopping list and living their lives with malnutrition.
Food stability and people's livelihoods
-
García-Díez et al. argued that food stability arises when an individual or household has access to food at all times and can ride out economic crises, political turmoil, and natural hazards events such as a flash flooding or a drought season[32].
Economic crisis, climatic factors, and food stability
-
Food stability does not necessarily refer to the prices of foods alone; however, it should consider the availability of daily foods and their nutritious status over time. All the informants argued that the production of Aman rice during the last season has drastically fallen due to the recent drought and flash floods in the northern region of the country. Additionally, irrigation for Boro rice has been seriously compromised because of the drought. The study revealed that the government has substantially increased the price of fertilizer urea, amid the existing concerns. One informant reflected the overall findings of the study and stated that, 'if the peasants feel demotivated to produce crops, clouds of uncertainty will shroud our food security'. One FGD interviewee stated that, 'amid the growing concern, a suggestion came up from the government's side for its citizens to consume rice flour instead of wheat flour, which is meaningless. The government instead could advise people to consume conventional food that should have their purchasing capacity '. Another informant added: 'The government is mandated to make the food supply smooth'.
The study found that how the current economic condition creates significant impediments for people to purchase less food and prices of almost every commodity in the market have gone up by about 20% to 25%. The study found that the informants have curtailed the use of their daily necessities to live their lives in the current situation and have ceased buying some food products permanently (Table 2). According to one FGD participant, 'I am a diabetic patient who could not eat rice. I wanted to get some flour, however, I could only manage one packet of atta, as the stock has already finished '.
Table 2. Two factors affecting food security in terms of 'Four Pillars'
The state of food availability Daily foodstuffs are not sufficiently available in nearby shops or markets meaning that people cannot adequately purchase and consume them. People do not shop at the closest available grocery shop because they lack enough money or other resources. Many consumers purchase their staple foodstuff to shop at a grocery shop, irrespective of their food security status. The degree of food accessibility 1. High food prices shape whether consumers will have access to food. 2. Higher food prices lead to people's less access to food, particularly for low-income people or households. 3. Individual or household resources, such as laod, mooey, and other household resources may also contribute to the conditions of food security. 4. Access to transportation play a vital role in getting access to food access. 5. Public transportation may facilitate people's access to food, particularly for those with no transportation, albeit routes would need to be available so that people can reach neighborhoods with supermarkets. The state of food utilization People lack dietary quality foodstuffs which is crucial for their meotal aod physical health. Food insecurity is continuously associated with a wide variety of worse health outcomes, and poorer general health. Food stability The lack of capacity to buy adequate safe and nutritious food during climatic hazards aod economic crisis Food production and distribution are oot stable, volatile price stability, inadequate import flow stability, Source: IDls and FCDs, 2022 -
The study explored the level of food security among the people in the study area in terms of the four pillars - availability, accessibility, utilization, and stability - that are important to the informants in the study locale. The findings revealed that many people do not have the means to purchase necessary food on a daily basis. Domestic food production has been seriously hampered as the costs of food production, such as oil prices, seeds, and other production costs soared. The findings convincingly reflected on the status of the other three pillars of the food security situation in rural Bangladesh. The access to food by informants demonstrates that people lacked substantially enough purchasing capacity, given that prices of each staple food have seriously increased. Moreover, the physical distance required to get daily foodstuffs has prevented people from purchasing food. Thus, people have to go to bed with only a minimum amount of food which leads to potential long-term hunger. The study revealed daily per capita consumption of calories, and nutrient foods do not meet the standard level that informants require. They do not receive adequate food and the necessary daily calories. Regarding food stability, it is revealed that climate change-related hazards, such as drought and flash floods have seriously hampered this year's production of Aman rice in the northern region of Bangladesh. Added to this, the high prices of urea and oil have disrupted the production of staple foods. These factors have accelerated less stable food production in the region. Thus, food security has been hugely affected.
The research, however, has a few limitations which mostly rely on employing the qualitative methods. The study followed thoroughly the qualitative method in the entire process of data collection, and analysis. In line with the methods, we collected qualitative data and presented them using thematic techniques. First, the method, by its nature, did not allow us to provide comprehensive insights into the study's aims and objectives. Second, the number of informants might be another drawback as 40 informants might not be enough to provide vivid pictures and in-depth information central to the research objectives. Apart from these, our positionality affects to collect and present data on an impartial basis as the researchers were born and brought up in the same study place. In order to overcome the limitations, we kept ourselves in a neutral stance so that informants did not feel any hesitations to provide the required data. Last but not least, applying a quantitative approach could have helped us to obtain and analyze data in a more comprehensive manner which could facilitate in presenting data in a more generalized way.
The current research plays a vital role in developing a real picture of the recent price hikes and associated adverse effects on people living in the study area. The outcomes of the research will help policymakers to devise practical and effective strategies for mitigating the dangers posed by rising prices of foodstuffs. Future research should focus on revealing the various causes of the current food insecurity in the country. In so doing, future studies should be designed to help relevant ministries of the GoB to take necessary steps to mitigate the current barriers to food security. The concerted efforts would greatly benefit the masses as well as the proposed strategies to help them escape from the precarious situation of food insecurity in the country. Thus, the basic needs of its inhabitants will be sufficiently managed which aims at leading a sustainable livelihood.
Finally, this research paper concludes that examining food security as experienced by informants is multi-dimensional. Food security has a variety of meanings relevant to a specific context or dimension covering the 'what' aspect. The 'why' aspect explains the various reasons illustrated above for food insecurity, while the 'how' dimension covers the methodological framework that was employed to answer the question devised for this research.
The research suggests urgent evidence-based recommendations to be carried out which are as follows:
(i) The Government of Bangladesh (GoB) should find out for a new market from which essential daily foods, such as rice and wheat can be imported at fair prices.
(ii) The GoB needs to take action to protect the socio-economically poor by meeting their consumption and production requirements. Social protection strategies need to be put in place to align with the country's current challenges but also what it seeks to achieve.
(iii) It is evident that the global market may remain unstable for quite some time because of the current Russia-Ukraine war. Therefore, the government should take steps to ensure that the country's food grain supplies remain stable for the near future.
(iv) The government must prioritize local production of foodstuffs provide the required policies, and then ensure that these are actually enforced.
(v) There is an urgent need to bring down prices so that the extremely poor have some means to pay them and to expand and improve OMS services so that the most vulnerable people in society are not left behind.
-
About this article
Cite this article
Rahman MM, Ferdousee S. 2023. Food security among the people living in rural Bangladesh: insights from the northern region of the country. Circular Agricultural Systems 3:10 doi: 10.48130/CAS-2023-0010
Food security among the people living in rural Bangladesh: insights from the northern region of the country
- Received: 17 June 2023
- Accepted: 31 August 2023
- Published online: 24 November 2023
Abstract: The main objective of this study is to explore the food security status among people living in rural Bangladesh. This paper draws on data collected during a field study conducted between September 15 and October 30, 2022. The study examines the 'Food Security Approach' developed by the Food and Agricultural Organization. This research investigated the current state of food availability, accessibility, utilization, and food stability among purposively selected informants in the study area. The study utilizes qualitative research tools, specifically in-depth interviews (IDIs), and focus group discussions (FGDs). In total, 40 informants were chosen followed by purposive sampling and five FGDs were administered. It emerged that daily foodstuffs are not sufficiently available in nearby shops or markets to meet people's daily consumption needs. High food prices and transportation issues are meaningful indicators that shape whether food is accessible to consumers. A lack of a wide variety of dietary foods indicates the current state of food stability, while recent inflation and climatic factors such as drought and flash floods lead to food shortages. The research recommends that the government of Bangladesh (GoB) should upgrade social protection programs through Open Market Sales (OMS), and the informal sector to improve both people's consumption and production of food so that it is secured in the study area.
-
Key words:
- Food availability /
- Accessibility /
- Utilization /
- Stability /
- Food security /
- Rural Bangladesh.