HTML
-
The economic importance of WEF exists on multiple levels. The most basic level is the commercialization in local communities in which the gatherers directly participate, the next level is the sale of WEF in regional markets carried out by 1–2 broker chains, followed by sale in national markets conducted by chains of up to 3 to 5 brokers. A crucial factor to consider is that in developing countries, mushroom pickers, regardless of gender, often belong to marginalized groups. Mushrooms are accordingly an important source of family income during harvest time, given the vulnerable socioeconomic status of mushroom collectors in parts of Africa, Mesoamerica and Eastern Asia. Little data exist regarding the commercialization of WEF in domestic markets around the world. However, there are some examples that are emblematic of what might exist globally. For example, in some Mexican communities, it has been documented that up to 100% of family income during the wet season comes from mushroom harvesting (Pérez-Moreno et al. 2010). In western North America, WEF collection constitutes an important source of income for immigrant groups coming from mycophilic cultures (Pilz & Molina 2002); and in China, there has been a radical change in the social position of previously marginalized groups that have traditionally collected and sold WEF such as matsutake (Arora 2008).
At the highest level, WEF are traded internationally for billions of US dollars annually (Table 1). Some species fetch exorbitant prices, placing some WEF among the world's most expensive foods. Some examples of these are as follows: i) In 2019 one fruiting body of the European white truffle (Tuber magnatum), weighing 1.005 kg, was sold for USD 145, 000 at an auction in the "89th International Alba White Truffle Fair" in Alba, Italy (AFP 2019); ii) Japanese matsutake (Tricholoma matsutake) can be worth up to USD 2, 000 per kg, and USD 1, 000 per kg during the beginning of the season in Tokyo is a common price (Japan Info 2020); iii) Perigord black truffle (Tuber melanosporum) prices ranged from USD 2, 811 to 3, 565 per kg from November 2019 to July 2020 (Truffle farm 2020); and iv) Annual world production of chanterelles (Cantharellus cibarius s.l.) ranges from 150, 000 to 200, 000 tonnes with an estimated value of USD 1.67 billion (Watling 1997). In addition to these examples, there are a number of WEF whose international commercial value is of relevance due to their exceptionally high level of production, e.g., Porcini (Boletus edulis s.l.), Caesar's mushroom (Amanita sect. Caesarea), Morels (Morchella spp.), Saffron Milk caps (Lactarius sect. Deliciousus) and Coral Fungi (Ramaria spp.). For example, a Finnish company harvested 1, 100 tons of WEF in a year, mainly porcini, with a revenue of USD 7.4 million (Cai et al. 2011).
Table 1. Highly prized wild edible fungi and estimated world trade value in US dollars
Common Name Scientific name Annual in-season retail market Wholesale price (per kilogram, grade one) Chanterelle Cantharellus cibarius s.l. $1.67 billion $\$$8 to $\$$22 Chinese black truffle Tuber indicum $\$$170milliona $\$$50 to $\$$200b Desert truffle Terfezia spp. and Tirmania spp. Unknownc $\$$27 to 334 Ganbajun Thelephora ganbajun Unknownd $\$$50 to $\$$250 Italian white truffle Tuber magnatum $\$$150 million $\$$1, 000 to $\$$7, 500b Matsutake Tricholoma matsutake s.l. $\$$500 million $\$$30 to $\$$1, 000 Périgord black truffle Tuber melanosporum $\$$150 million $\$$250 to $\$$3, 200b Porcini Boletus edulis s.l. $\$$250 million $\$$13 to $\$$198 Updated from Pérez-Moreno & Martinez-Reyes 2014; aestimation based on an average price of USD 170 provided by Truffle farm (2020) and a production of 1, 000 tonnes (Bin et al. 2021). bBased on retail prices in 2019 in Truffle farm (2020); cmostly sold in Arab countries with no official data available; dmostly sold in domestic markets in Southwestern China, without current accurate estimations of natural production. International trade of WEF has increased dramatically in recent decades. According to United Nations data, the volume of WEF trade has increased more than three-fold in the last 15 years (Fig. 7). The main variables that seem to drive this growing business are dynamic changes of trade relations between developed countries, income (gross domestic product) changes in some countries, and modification of consumption habits (including the increasing desire for healthy foods and diet diversification). The countries that have shown the greatest increase in trade of WEF between 2002 and 2017 in America are Canada, Mexico and Peru; in Europe they are Belgium, Bulgaria, Latvia, Macedonia and Romania; in Africa it is Belgian Congo; in Asia they are Armenia, Azerbaijan, Bhutan, India, Kyrgyzstan and Pakistan; and in Australasia it is New Zealand (de Frutos 2020). In addition to these figures, it should be considered that the domestic trade in many countries, such as Australia, China, France, Italy, Japan, Mexico, New Zealand and Spain, has yet to be holistically evaluated and likely accounts for millions of USD annually (Fig. 8).
Figure 7. Annual global trade of edible wild mushrooms and truffles from 2002 to 2017. Graph created with data from the United Nations published by de Frutos (2020). "Total" includes the sum of international mushroom and truffle trade indexes labelled with the codes 070959 (truffles and mushrooms fresh or chilled), 071159 (mushrooms, provisionally preserved but unsuitable in that state for immediate consumption), 071239 (mushrooms and truffles, whole, cut sliced, broken or in powder but not further prepared, dried), and 200390 (mushrooms prepared or preserved otherwise than by vinegar or acetic acid). Meanwhile "Fresh or chilled" refers only to international trade labelled with the trade code 070959 (truffles and mushrooms fresh or chilled).
Figure 8. Economic relevance of edible mushrooms in different continents. A Mexican gourmet dish with the native "Blue milk cap" (Lactarius indigo). B Chinese gourmet desert with Asian truffles (Tuber indicum); C Vodka aged for 5 years with Cantharellus cibarius s.l. in Russia; D Complex factory of enoki mushrooms (Flammulina velutipes) in Nagano, Japan with an annual production of 300 thousand tonnes. E Specialized store selling Périgord black truffle (Tuber melanosporum) products in Cahors, France. F Hazel and oak tree plantation "Tewnion Truffiere" which produce high quality Périgord Black Truffles in Christchurch, New Zealand.
Currently cultivation of edible saprotrophic mushrooms constitutes a multibillion-dollar industry, with cutting edge technological applications. For example, in Suwa, Japan, there is an industrial complex dedicated exclusively to the cultivation of enokitake mushrooms (Flammulina velutipes), where more than 300, 000 tonnes are produced per year. Amazingly, as most of the processes are automated, the factory complex is run by only 200 workers. Furthermore, a novel stream of income for rural communities might exist in the future via the large-scale trade of edible ectomycorrhizal mushrooms used to produce bioinoculants useful for forest plant production, which are critical to ensuring the success of reforestation efforts (Pérez-Moreno et al. 2020c).
-
Our coexistence with fungi dates back nearly 20, 000 years. Indeed, WEF have left an indelible mark on the evolution of all life forms on earth. Most of the 2, 200-known species of WEF establish ectomycorrhizal symbiosis with plant roots, accounting for 54% of total fungi, with the remaining 46% either saprotrophic (43%) or parasitic (3%). Surprisingly, only a small proportion of WEF are cultivated commercially or at an industrial scale (around 4.5%). These facts suggest that developing strategies to preserve WEF genetic resources for the purposes of food security is extremely relevant. Hundreds of WEF have traditionally been important biocultural resources critical to the livelihood strategies of poor rural communities in low or middle-income countries. On a larger scale, WEF global trade is worth billions of dollars; according to the United Nations, more than 1.2 billion tonnes were commercialized in 2017 alone. Furthermore, the volume of this trade has increased more than three-fold in the last 15 years. Therefore, WEF constitute an important natural resource which, if used sustainably, can contribute to food security, creation of jobs and hunger mitigation in the post-pandemic era to come.
J Pérez-Moreno, PE Mortimer, J Xu, SC Karunarathna, H Li. 2021. Global perspectives on the ecological, cultural and socioeconomic relevance of wild edible fungi. Studies in Fungi 6(1):408−424 doi: 10.5943/sif/6/1/31 |